Saturday, November 21, 2026

"The Price" at Gremlin Theatre

Artur Miller's Death of a Salesman recently won a Tony for best revival. Bryan Cranston is headlining a revival of All My Sons next spring. The Crucible is often produced, and inspired the new play John Proctor is the Villain which is part of the Guthrie's season. But the prolific American playwright wrote many plays, most of which are not in frequent rotation like the big ones are. Gremlin Theatre has uncovered one such gem, the 1968 Tony-nominated The Price (fun fact: it lost to Rosencrantz and Gildenstern are Dead). It did have a Broadway revival about ten years ago starring Mark Ruffalo and Tony Shalhoub, but to my knowledge it hasn't been produced in #TCTheater in at least 15 or 20 years. The small-cast two-act play is perhaps the funniest Arthur Miller work I've seen, but it's also devastating in that specific Arthur Miller way. When two estranged brothers are forced to sell the contents of their long-dead father's home before the building is torn down, it dredges up all sorts of traumas and ghosts of the past. It's a beautifully real and human story, and this production features a fantastic four-person cast. While not a holiday show, it is appropriate for the holiday season which brings families together to reminisce about the past - the good, the bad, and the ugly. See The Price at Gremlin Theatre now through December 6.

The entire play is essentially one long scene that plays out in one location in real time, split by an intermission. That in itself makes it unique, and engrossing as you get drawn into the intense and unrelenting family drama. The story begins when Victor, a police officer nearing retirement, enters his father's NYC apartment, that's been gathering dust for 16 years. He finds his old fencing gear, and plays a few albums on the record player. His wife Esther shows up, eager to get to their movie date, but Victor is waiting for the appraiser he called to come and look at the furniture. He eventually shows up, the almost 90-year-old former acrobat Russian immigrant thrice-married (or was it four times?) Mr. Solomon, who in a Colombo-esque way seems to not quite have it together, but offers a shrewd price. We eventually learn that Victor left school to care for his father after he lost all his money in the depression and his wife died, while Victor's brother Walter left the family and became a successful doctor. When Walter unexpectedly appears, things get complicated. He wants to make amends with Victor, but at what price? And what about the price that has already been paid because of the choices they made decades ago that defined the trajectory of their lives?

brothers Walter (David Mann) and Victor (Peter Christian Hansen)
(photo courtesy of Gremlin Theatre)
The play is beautifully paced, directed by Gremlin's resident director Ellen Fenster Gharib, with a continuous flow of storytelling. There are awkward pauses, and time for things to sink in, but it never drags throughout the 2+ hour runtime. The humor is nicely balanced with the drama, and we really dig into the relationships between all of the characters. Artistic Director Peter Christian Hansen disappears inside the role of Victor, showing the depths of emotion of this man who so desperately wants to reconnect with his brother but is still deeply hurt. He's paired well with Sandra Struthers as Esther, who makes her a strong character and partner to Victor, despite the limitations of the gender roles of the '60s. David Mann shows up just before intermission as the long-discussed Walter, and perfectly embodies the reserved doctor who thinks he can wash away decades of history with a job offer. Rounding out this excellent cast and providing much of the humor is Michael Paul Levin as Mr. Solomon, who, despite being too young for the role, is so charming and funny as this eccentric man full of stories, and happy to tell them.

Gremlin's stage has been transformed into this cluttered NYC apartment, and it looks like they just rummaged through their storage room and piled every piece of vintage furniture they could find on the stage! There's no backdrop, so the chests, wardrobes, tables, chairs, lamps, rolled up rugs, and more are crammed into the back corners. There's even a harp in one corner of the stage, frequently referenced in the script as the instrument their mother played. The sound design occasionally reminds us that we're in NYC, and when a couple of records are played on the vintage record player, we hear the scratchy sound coming from it. Each character is dressed in '60s era clothing that tells us who they are, from Victor's authentic-looking police uniform, complete with hat, to Esther's smart suit jacket and skirt (commented on several times), to Walter's expensive-looking gray suit with a gorgeous overcoat. (Set and lighting design by Carl Schoenborn, sound design by Aaron Newman, costume and prop design by Sarah Bauer.)

The Price is playing for three weekends only - don't miss your chance to see this lesser known work by one of the greatest American playwrights of the 20th Century.