Monday, November 16, 2026

"A Christmas Carol" at the Guthrie Theater

The Guthrie has been doing A Christmas Carol for over 50 years now, and as a 22-year season subscriber, I saw it for the 20th time yesterday. Yes, I missed two years (it's not actually a part of the season subscription, but you can use subscriber discounts), but I make every effort to see it every year. Why? To put it simply, it makes me happy. It's that warm and familiar comfort food that signals it's the holiday* season, and everything about it is so thoughtfully and gorgeously constructed. Many things are the same as last year, but some things have changed as well. This is the sixth year using this succinct and faithful adaptation by Lavina Jadhwani that has the ensemble serving as narrators, and the absolutely stunning design, and the director from the past few years Addie Gorlin-Han returns (based on Joseph Haj's original direction). But we have a new Scrooge this year, as well as a couple other cast changes, which brings a new energy and dynamic. But what hasn't changed is the beautiful beating heart of the original story and this production, that it's never too late to change and grow and become a better person, that gratitude, kindness, and generosity are the highest of virtues.** Continue the tradition, or start a new one, with the goodness and light and cozy Victorian Christmas feel of A Christmas Carol at the Guthrie. It's playing through December 27, and be sure to check the website for special events happening throughout the run of the show (I stumbled upon a Christmas carol singalong!).

Scrooge (Andrew May) and Fred (Daniel Petzold)
(photo by Dan Norman)
We've seen Andrew May a couple of times on the Guthrie stage, most notably as Agatha Christie's most beloved detective Poirot in Murder on the Orient Express. Now he dons Scrooge's nightcap in a funny, heartfelt, and all-around delightful performance. His Scrooge is gruff and loud in his distaste of... everything, but he visibly softens with each thing the ghosts show him, so that at the end he's full of new life. The only other new cast member this year is Erik Ohno Dagoberg as young Scrooge, beautifully playing the opposite transition from the sweet young Scrooge to the beginnings of the hardened businessman. Daniel Petzold moves over from this role in last year's production to Scrooge's nephew Fred, the epitome of goodness and the only one to see Scrooge's humanity all along, never giving up hope that he'll return to it.

when Belle (Stephanie Anne Bertumen) met Ebenezer
(Erik Ohno Dagober, photo by Dan Norman)
The rest of the 18-person cast remains the same and includes some of the best actors in town. Some of them have been with the show for a few years, some for a few decades, and they all move together smoothly as they pass the narration between them, and play multiple roles. They're joined by eight additional adult actors who have no lines but fill out the rich world of the story, and six adorable children. That adds up to 30 people onstage, but it never feels chaotic or crowded, but rather graceful and precise.

Matt Saunders' set design is stunning, effective, and haunting, and features many moving parts and pieces that separate and combine to create the different locations of the story. Rotating concentric circles bring set pieces on and off (tiny houses, gravestones, streetlamps, and more), and create interest in movement of the actors. A sliding backdrop of London buildings moves to reveal a massive two-story rotating piece that is Scrooge's abode. A huge metal staircase piece is utilized in several different ways including as the deck of a ship. Combined with the lighting (designed by Yi Zhao), the effect is a dark Victorian cityscape that is also filled with magic and wonder.**

the Ghost of Christmas Present (Regina Marie Williams) and Scrooge
(Andrew May) visit the Cratchit family (photo by Dan Norman)
The gorgeous and lush Victorian costumes (designed by Toni-Leslie James) range from rich and deeply colored gowns (with gigantic skirts) and suits with every imaginable detail (top hats!), to the modest garb of the lower classes, to the colorful and fantastical costumes of the ghosts. And while this isn't a musical, there are many moments of music, both as interstitials and of course the Fezziwig party scene. The cast sings beautiful and festive Victorian Christmas carols, either a capella or to a recorded track (with music direction by Jason Hansen). The lovely dancing and movement (including a cool clock formation) leaves you wanting more (choreography by Regina Peluso, recreated by Joey Miller). In fact this is a rare show that felt too short, I wasn't ready for it to end; it does not overstay its welcome, leaving you satiated but not overstuffed.**