For the past four Decembers, The Ordway Center for the Performing Arts has produced Ordway Original holiday* shows - large-scale Broadway-style musicals using local talent. We had the delightfully nostalgic A Christmas Story in 2014
, one of my personal favorites The Sound of Music in 2015
, the sumptuous White Christmas in 2016
, and the wonderful Annie
last year. The last three calendar years have seen at least three Ordway Originals; perhaps 2017 was the high point, in which they also produced a gorgeous West Side Story
, an explosive Jesus Christ Superstar
, and a fantastic In the Heights
(Lin-Manuel Miranda's first work). Coming off of that high point, and after the departure of Producing Artistic Director James Rocco, the Ordway has chosen to bring in a touring production this December, after only one Original this year (the super fun Mamma Mia!
). I can't say I'm not disappointed. It's not that Elf the Musica
l (a non-equity tour
) isn't a fine selection - bright and sweet and fun and very Christmassy - it's just that I've come to expect more from the Ordway. All that being said, I'm certain that the children who showed up opening night with elf hats on their heads and excitement in their eyes didn't know the difference, and likely some of their parents didn't either. So let's move on to the perfectly satisfactory Elf, which runs through the end of December
The musical adaptation of the beloved 2003 movie
, in which Will Ferrell plays a man-child raised to believe he's an elf, premiered on Broadway on 2010. It's a fairly faithful adaptation; I had just re-watched the movie that day so I recognized some scenes and even lines. To make a two and a half hour long story short, Buddy the Elf (the adorably exuberant Sam Hartley) leaves his North Pole home to find his biological father, a business man in NYC named Walter Hobbs (Joel Stigliano). Mr. Hobbs is less than enthusiastic, having little time for the son he already has. But eventually the family warms to Buddy, who is pure goodness and joy. He ends up working in the Christmas display at Macy's, which is of course more than a job to him. But when Buddy interrupts an important business deal (the Peter Dinklage cameo has been replaced with some predictable business involving a shredder), Walter gets upset and Buddy runs away. Mom (Marie Lemon) and son (Tristan Klaphake) advocate on Buddy's behalf, Walter has a change of heart (a la Scrooge and the Grinch), and they all help Santa when he crash lands in Central Park, thereby saving Christmas! The story is nicely framed by a jovial Santa (Ken Clement) addressing the audience and reading the story of Buddy the Elf, throwing in a few jokes for the grown-ups (Game of Thrones
|Santa (Ken Clement) and Buddy (Sam Hartley)|
(photo by Jeremy Daniels)
Despite my general dislike for the movie-turned-musical (give me an original musical any day!), Elf
flows pretty naturally into a musical, because Buddy loves to sing, and we've already thrown disbelief out the window buying into this story of an actual elf. It's already a heightened, magical sort of world, which feels like a natural musical. The music is fun and catchy (performed by a ten-ish-piece pit orchestra under conductor Sean P. Cameron); the highlight being the jazzy "The Story of Buddy the Elf." The score also provides some great character moments, like "Never Fall In Love (with an Elf)" (good advice, that), belted by Mackenzie Lesser-Roy's Jovie, the less than Jovial elf whom Buddy befriends. The entire 20+ person cast does a wonderful job playing multiple characters and dancing festively, either on their feet or knees as the elves.
The set (designed by Christine Peters) is a two-dimensional winter wonderland, and also represents the greatest city in the world (NYC, obvs) as a thing of cartoonish dreams. Costumes (designed by Gregg Barnes) are colorful and very elf-like, creating a fun and festive atmosphere on stage.
Elf the Musical
is a wonderful story of believing in magic, but the magic I want to see more of on the Ordway stage is that created by our fabulous #TCTheater artists.
Dear Santa, please bring me more Ordway Originals next year! (A little elf tells me my Christmas wish may be granted with at least two next year - stay tuned.)
*You can read about all of the holiday shows I've seen here